arrow_back

GKE Workload Optimization

Join Sign in
Test and share your knowledge with our community!
done
Get access to over 700 hands-on labs, skill badges, and courses

GKE Workload Optimization

Lab 1 hour 30 minutes universal_currency_alt 5 Credits show_chart Intermediate
Test and share your knowledge with our community!
done
Get access to over 700 hands-on labs, skill badges, and courses

GSP769

Google Cloud self-paced labs logo

Overview

One of the many benefits of using Google Cloud is its billing model that bills you for only the resources you use. With that in mind, it's imperative that you not only allocate a reasonable amount of resources for your apps and infrastructure, but that you make the most efficient use of them. With GKE there are a number of tools and strategies available to you that can reduce the use of different resources and services while also improving your application's availability.

This lab will walk through a few concepts that will help increase the resource efficiency and availability of your workloads. By understanding and fine-tuning your cluster's workload, you can better ensure you are only using the resources you need and optimizing your cluster's costs.

Objectives

In this lab, you will learn how to:

  • Create a container-native load balancer through ingress
  • Load test an application
  • Configure liveness and readiness probes
  • Create a pod disruption budget

Setup and requirements

Before you click the Start Lab button

Read these instructions. Labs are timed and you cannot pause them. The timer, which starts when you click Start Lab, shows how long Google Cloud resources will be made available to you.

This hands-on lab lets you do the lab activities yourself in a real cloud environment, not in a simulation or demo environment. It does so by giving you new, temporary credentials that you use to sign in and access Google Cloud for the duration of the lab.

To complete this lab, you need:

  • Access to a standard internet browser (Chrome browser recommended).
Note: Use an Incognito or private browser window to run this lab. This prevents any conflicts between your personal account and the Student account, which may cause extra charges incurred to your personal account.
  • Time to complete the lab---remember, once you start, you cannot pause a lab.
Note: If you already have your own personal Google Cloud account or project, do not use it for this lab to avoid extra charges to your account.

How to start your lab and sign in to the Google Cloud console

  1. Click the Start Lab button. If you need to pay for the lab, a pop-up opens for you to select your payment method. On the left is the Lab Details panel with the following:

    • The Open Google Cloud console button
    • Time remaining
    • The temporary credentials that you must use for this lab
    • Other information, if needed, to step through this lab
  2. Click Open Google Cloud console (or right-click and select Open Link in Incognito Window if you are running the Chrome browser).

    The lab spins up resources, and then opens another tab that shows the Sign in page.

    Tip: Arrange the tabs in separate windows, side-by-side.

    Note: If you see the Choose an account dialog, click Use Another Account.
  3. If necessary, copy the Username below and paste it into the Sign in dialog.

    {{{user_0.username | "Username"}}}

    You can also find the Username in the Lab Details panel.

  4. Click Next.

  5. Copy the Password below and paste it into the Welcome dialog.

    {{{user_0.password | "Password"}}}

    You can also find the Password in the Lab Details panel.

  6. Click Next.

    Important: You must use the credentials the lab provides you. Do not use your Google Cloud account credentials. Note: Using your own Google Cloud account for this lab may incur extra charges.
  7. Click through the subsequent pages:

    • Accept the terms and conditions.
    • Do not add recovery options or two-factor authentication (because this is a temporary account).
    • Do not sign up for free trials.

After a few moments, the Google Cloud console opens in this tab.

Note: To view a menu with a list of Google Cloud products and services, click the Navigation menu at the top-left. Navigation menu icon

Activate Cloud Shell

Cloud Shell is a virtual machine that is loaded with development tools. It offers a persistent 5GB home directory and runs on the Google Cloud. Cloud Shell provides command-line access to your Google Cloud resources.

  1. Click Activate Cloud Shell Activate Cloud Shell icon at the top of the Google Cloud console.

When you are connected, you are already authenticated, and the project is set to your Project_ID, . The output contains a line that declares the Project_ID for this session:

Your Cloud Platform project in this session is set to {{{project_0.project_id | "PROJECT_ID"}}}

gcloud is the command-line tool for Google Cloud. It comes pre-installed on Cloud Shell and supports tab-completion.

  1. (Optional) You can list the active account name with this command:
gcloud auth list
  1. Click Authorize.

Output:

ACTIVE: * ACCOUNT: {{{user_0.username | "ACCOUNT"}}} To set the active account, run: $ gcloud config set account `ACCOUNT`
  1. (Optional) You can list the project ID with this command:
gcloud config list project

Output:

[core] project = {{{project_0.project_id | "PROJECT_ID"}}} Note: For full documentation of gcloud, in Google Cloud, refer to the gcloud CLI overview guide.

Provision lab environment

  1. Set your default zone to "":
gcloud config set compute/zone {{{project_0.default_zone|ZONE}}}
  1. Click Authorize.

  2. Create a three node cluster:

gcloud container clusters create test-cluster --num-nodes=3 --enable-ip-alias

The --enable-ip-alias flag is included in order to enable the use of alias IPs for pods which will be required for container-native load balancing through an ingress.

For this lab, you'll use a simple HTTP web app that you will first deploy as a single pod.

  1. Create a manifest for the gb-frontend pod:
cat << EOF > gb_frontend_pod.yaml apiVersion: v1 kind: Pod metadata: labels: app: gb-frontend name: gb-frontend spec: containers: - name: gb-frontend image: gcr.io/google-samples/gb-frontend-amd64:v5 resources: requests: cpu: 100m memory: 256Mi ports: - containerPort: 80 EOF
  1. Apply the newly created manifest to your cluster:
kubectl apply -f gb_frontend_pod.yaml Note: You may need to wait for 1 to 2 minutes to get the score for this task.

Click Check my progress to verify the objective. Provision Lab Environment

Task 1. Container-native load balancing through ingress

Container-native load balancing allows load balancers to target Kubernetes Pods directly and to evenly distribute traffic to pods.

Without container-native load balancing, load balancer traffic would travel to node instance groups and then be routed via iptables rules to pods which may or may not be in the same node:

Load balancer traffic flow

Container-native load balancing allows pods to become the core objects for load balancing, potentially reducing the number of network hops:

Load balancer traffic flow

In addition to more efficient routing, container-native load balancing results in substantially reduced network utilization,improved performance, even distribution of traffic across Pods, and application-level health checks.

In order to take advantage of container-native load balancing, the VPC-native setting must be enabled on the cluster. This was indicated when you created the cluster and included the --enable-ip-alias flag.

  1. The following manifest will configure a ClusterIP service that will be used to route traffic to your application pod to allow GKE to create a network endpoint group:
cat << EOF > gb_frontend_cluster_ip.yaml apiVersion: v1 kind: Service metadata: name: gb-frontend-svc annotations: cloud.google.com/neg: '{"ingress": true}' spec: type: ClusterIP selector: app: gb-frontend ports: - port: 80 protocol: TCP targetPort: 80 EOF

The manifest includes an annotations field where the annotation for cloud.google.com/neg will enable container-native load balancing on for your application when an ingress is created.

  1. Apply the change to your cluster:
kubectl apply -f gb_frontend_cluster_ip.yaml
  1. Next, create an ingress for your application:
cat << EOF > gb_frontend_ingress.yaml apiVersion: networking.k8s.io/v1 kind: Ingress metadata: name: gb-frontend-ingress spec: defaultBackend: service: name: gb-frontend-svc port: number: 80 EOF
  1. Apply the change to your cluster:
kubectl apply -f gb_frontend_ingress.yaml

When the ingress is created, an HTTP(S) load balancer is created along with an NEG (Network Endpoint Group) in each zone in which the cluster runs. After a few minutes, the ingress will be assigned an external IP.

The load balancer it created has a backend service running in your project that defines how Cloud Load Balancing distributes traffic. This backend service has a health status associated with it.

  1. To check the health status of the backend service, first retrieve the name:
BACKEND_SERVICE=$(gcloud compute backend-services list | grep NAME | cut -d ' ' -f2)
  1. Get the health status for the service:
gcloud compute backend-services get-health $BACKEND_SERVICE --global

It will take a few minutes before your health check returns a healthy status.

Output will look something like this:

--- backend: https://www.googleapis.com/compute/v1/projects/qwiklabs-gcp-00-27ced9534cde/zones/us-central1-a/networkEndpointGroups/k8s1-95c051f0-default-gb-frontend-svc-80-9b127192 status: healthStatus: - healthState: HEALTHY instance: https://www.googleapis.com/compute/v1/projects/qwiklabs-gcp-00-27ced9534cde/zones/us-central1-a/instances/gke-test-cluster-default-pool-7e74f027-47qp ipAddress: 10.8.0.6 port: 80 kind: compute#backendServiceGroupHealth Note: These health checks are part of the Google Cloud load balancer and are distinct from the liveness and readiness probes provided by the Kubernetes API which can be used to determine the health of individual pods. The Google Cloud load balancer health checks use special routes outside of your project’s VPC to perform health checks and determine the success or failure of a backend.

Once the health state for each instance reports as HEALTHY, you can access the application via its external IP.

  1. Retrieve it with:
kubectl get ingress gb-frontend-ingress
  1. Entering the external IP in a browser window will load the application.

Click Check my progress to verify the objective. Container-native Load Balancing Through Ingress

Task 2. Load testing an application

Understanding your application capacity is an important step to take when choosing resource requests and limits for your application's pods and for deciding the best auto-scaling strategy.

At the start of the lab, you deployed your app as a single pod. By load testing your application running on a single pod with no autoscaling configured, you will learn how many concurrent requests your application can handle, how much CPU and memory it requires, and how it might respond to heavy load.

To load test your pod, you'll use Locust, an open source load-testing framework.

  1. Download the Docker image files for Locust in your Cloud Shell:
gsutil -m cp -r gs://spls/gsp769/locust-image .

The files in the provided locust-image directory include Locust configuration files.

  1. Build the Docker image for Locust and store it in your project's container registry:
gcloud builds submit \ --tag gcr.io/${GOOGLE_CLOUD_PROJECT}/locust-tasks:latest locust-image
  1. Verify the Docker image is in your project's container registry:
gcloud container images list

Expected output:

Output: Only listing images in gcr.io/qwiklabs-gcp-01-343cd312530e.

Locust consists of a main and a number of worker machines to generate load.

  1. Copy and apply the manifest will create a single-pod deployment for the main and a 5-replica deployment for the workers:
gsutil cp gs://spls/gsp769/locust_deploy_v2.yaml . sed 's/${GOOGLE_CLOUD_PROJECT}/'$GOOGLE_CLOUD_PROJECT'/g' locust_deploy_v2.yaml | kubectl apply -f -
  1. To access the Locust UI, retrieve the external IP address of its corresponding LoadBalancer service:
kubectl get service locust-main

If your External IP value is <pending>, wait a minute and rerun the previous command until a valid value is displayed.

  1. In a new browser window, navigate to [EXTERNAL_IP_ADDRESS]:8089 to open the Locust web page:

Click Check my progress to verify the objective. Load Testing an Application

Locust allows you to swarm your application with many simultaneous users. You are able to simulate traffic by entering a number of users that are spawned at a certain rate.

  1. For this example, to represent a typical load, enter 200 for the number of users to simulate and 20 for the hatch rate.

  2. Click Start swarming.

After a few seconds, the status should read Running with 200 users and about 150 requests per second (RPS).

  1. Switch to the Cloud Console and click Navigation menu (Navigation menu) > Kubernetes Engine.

  2. Select Workloads from the left pane.

  3. Then click on your deployed gb-frontend pod.

This will bring you to the pod details page where you can view a graph of the CPU and memory utilization of your pod. Observe the used values and the requested values.

Pod details

Note: In order to see the metric values listed below the graph, click the three dots at the top right portion of the graph and select Expand chart legend from the dropdown.

With the current load test at about 150 requests per second, you may see the CPU utilization vary from as low as .04 and as high as .06. This represents 40-60% of your one pod's CPU request. On the other hand, memory utilization stays at around 80Mi, well below the requested 256Mi. This is your per-pod capacity. This information will be useful when configuring your Cluster Autoscaler, resource requests and limits, and choosing how or whether to implement a horizontal or vertical pod autoscaler.

Along with a baseline, you should also take into account how your application may perform after sudden bursts or spikes.

  1. Return to the Locust browser window and click Edit under the status at the top of the page.

  2. This time, enter 900 for the number of users to simulate and 300 for the hatch rate.

  3. Click Start Swarming.

Your pod will suddenly receive 700 additional requests within 2 - 3 seconds. After the RPS value reaches about 150 and the status indicates 900 users, switch back to the Pod Details page and observe the change in the graphs.

Pod details

While memory stays the same you'll see that CPU peaked at almost .07 - that's 70% of the CPU request for your pod. If this app were a deployment, you could probably safely reduce the total memory request to a lower amount and configure your horizontal autoscaler to trigger on CPU usage.

Task 3. Readiness and liveness probes

Setting up a liveness probe

If configured in the Kubernetes pod or deployment spec, a liveness probe will continuously run to detect whether a container requires a restart and trigger that restart. They are helpful for automatically restarting deadlocked applications that may still be in a running state. For example, a kubernetes-managed load balancer (such as a service) would only send traffic to a pod backend if all of its containers pass a readiness probe.

  1. To demonstrate a liveness probe, the following will generate a manifest for a pod that has a liveness probe based on the execution of the cat command on a file created on creation:
cat << EOF > liveness-demo.yaml apiVersion: v1 kind: Pod metadata: labels: demo: liveness-probe name: liveness-demo-pod spec: containers: - name: liveness-demo-pod image: centos args: - /bin/sh - -c - touch /tmp/alive; sleep infinity livenessProbe: exec: command: - cat - /tmp/alive initialDelaySeconds: 5 periodSeconds: 10 EOF
  1. Apply the manifest to your cluster to create the pod:
kubectl apply -f liveness-demo.yaml

The initialDelaySeconds value represents how long before the first probe should be performed after the container starts up. The periodSeconds value indicates how often the probe will be performed.

Note: Pods can also be configured to include a startupProbe which indicates whether the application within the container is started. If a startupProbe is present, no other probes will perform until it returns a Success state. This is recommended for applications that may have variable start-up times in order to avoid interruptions from a liveness probe.

In this example the liveness probe is essentially checking if the file /tmp/alive exists on the container's file system.

  1. You can verify the health of the pod's container by checking the pod's events:
kubectl describe pod liveness-demo-pod

At the bottom of the output there should be an Events section with the pod's last 5 events. At this point, the pod's events should only include the events related to its creation and start up:

Events: Type Reason Age From Message ---- ------ ---- ---- ------- Normal Scheduled 19s default-scheduler Successfully assigned default/liveness-demo-pod to gke-load-test-default-pool-abd43157-rgg0 Normal Pulling 18s kubelet Pulling image "centos" Normal Pulled 18s kubelet Successfully pulled image "centos" Normal Created 18s kubelet Created container liveness-demo-pod Normal Started 18s kubelet Started container liveness-demo-pod

This events log will include any failures in the liveness probe as well as restarts triggered as a result.

  1. Manually delete the file being used by the liveness probe:
kubectl exec liveness-demo-pod -- rm /tmp/alive
  1. With the file removed, the cat command being used by the liveness probe should return a non-zero exit code.

  2. Once again, check the pod's events:

kubectl describe pod liveness-demo-pod

As the liveness probe fails, you'll see events added to the log showing the series of steps that are kicked off. It will begin with the liveness probe failing (Liveness probe failed: cat: /tmp/alive: No such file or directory) and end with the container starting up once again (Started container):

Events: Type Reason Age From Message ---- ------ ---- ---- ------- Normal Scheduled 2m21s default-scheduler Successfully assigned default/liveness-demo-pod to gke-load-test-default-pool-abd43157-rgg0 Warning Unhealthy 36s (x3 over 56s) kubelet Liveness probe failed: cat: /tmp/alive: No such file or directory Normal Killing 36s kubelet Container liveness-demo-pod failed liveness probe, will be restarted Normal Pulling 6s (x2 over 2m20s) kubelet Pulling image "centos" Normal Pulled 6s (x2 over 2m20s) kubelet Successfully pulled image "centos" Normal Created 6s (x2 over 2m20s) kubelet Created container liveness-demo-pod Normal Started 6s (x2 over 2m20s) kubelet Started container liveness-demo-pod Note: The example in this lab uses a command probe for its livenessProbe that depends on the exit code of a specified command. In addition to a command probe, a livenessProbe could be configured as an HTTP probe that will depend on HTTP response, or a TCP probe that will depend on whether a TCP connection can be made on a specific port.

Setting up a readiness probe

Although a pod could successfully start and be considered healthy by a liveness probe, it's likely that it may not be ready to receive traffic right away. This is common for deployments that serve as a backend to a service such as a load balancer. A readiness probe is used to determine when a pod and its containers are ready to begin receiving traffic.

  1. To demonstrate this, create a manifest to create a single pod that will serve as a test web server along with a load balancer:
cat << EOF > readiness-demo.yaml apiVersion: v1 kind: Pod metadata: labels: demo: readiness-probe name: readiness-demo-pod spec: containers: - name: readiness-demo-pod image: nginx ports: - containerPort: 80 readinessProbe: exec: command: - cat - /tmp/healthz initialDelaySeconds: 5 periodSeconds: 5 --- apiVersion: v1 kind: Service metadata: name: readiness-demo-svc labels: demo: readiness-probe spec: type: LoadBalancer ports: - port: 80 targetPort: 80 protocol: TCP selector: demo: readiness-probe EOF
  1. Apply the manifest to your cluster and create a load balancer with it:
kubectl apply -f readiness-demo.yaml
  1. Retrieve the external IP address assigned to your load balancer (it may take a minute after the previous command for an address to be assigned):
kubectl get service readiness-demo-svc
  1. Enter the IP address in a browser window and you'll notice that you'll get an error message signifying that the site cannot be reached.

  2. Check the pod's events:

kubectl describe pod readiness-demo-pod

The output will reveal that the readiness probe has failed:

Events: Type Reason Age From Message ---- ------ ---- ---- ------- Normal Scheduled 2m24s default-scheduler Successfully assigned default/readiness-demo-pod to gke-load-test-default-pool-abd43157-rgg0 Normal Pulling 2m23s kubelet Pulling image "nginx" Normal Pulled 2m23s kubelet Successfully pulled image "nginx" Normal Created 2m23s kubelet Created container readiness-demo-pod Normal Started 2m23s kubelet Started container readiness-demo-pod Warning Unhealthy 35s (x21 over 2m15s) kubelet Readiness probe failed: cat: /tmp/healthz: No such file or directory

Unlike the liveness probe, an unhealthy readiness probe does not trigger the pod to restart.

  1. Use the following command to generate the file that the readiness probe is checking for:
kubectl exec readiness-demo-pod -- touch /tmp/healthz

The Conditions section of the pod description should now show True as the value for Ready.

kubectl describe pod readiness-demo-pod | grep ^Conditions -A 5

Output:

Conditions: Type Status Initialized True Ready True ContainersReady True PodScheduled True
  1. Now, refresh the browser tab that had your readiness-demo-svc external IP. You should see a "Welcome to nginx!" message properly displayed.

Setting meaningful readiness probes for your application containers ensures that pods are only receiving traffic when they are ready to do so. An example of a meaningful readiness probe is checking to see whether a cache your application relies on is loaded at startup.

Click Check my progress to verify the objective. Readiness and Liveness Probes

Task 4. Pod disruption budgets

Part of ensuring reliability and uptime for your GKE application relies on leveraging pod disruption budgets (pdp). PodDisruptionBudget is a Kubernetes resource that limits the number of pods of a replicated application that can be down simultaneously due to voluntary disruptions.

Voluntary disruptions include administrative actions like deleting a deployment, updating a deployment's pod template and performing a rolling update, draining nodes that an application's pods reside on, or moving pods to different nodes.

First, you'll have to deploy your application as a deployment.

  1. Delete your single pod app:
kubectl delete pod gb-frontend
  1. And generate a manifest that will create it as a deployment of 5 replicas:
cat << EOF > gb_frontend_deployment.yaml apiVersion: apps/v1 kind: Deployment metadata: name: gb-frontend labels: run: gb-frontend spec: replicas: 5 selector: matchLabels: run: gb-frontend template: metadata: labels: run: gb-frontend spec: containers: - name: gb-frontend image: gcr.io/google-samples/gb-frontend-amd64:v5 resources: requests: cpu: 100m memory: 128Mi ports: - containerPort: 80 protocol: TCP EOF
  1. Apply this deployment to your cluster:
kubectl apply -f gb_frontend_deployment.yaml

Click Check my progress to verify the objective. Create Pod Disruption Budgets

Before creating a PDB, you will drain your cluster's nodes and observe your application's behavior without a PDB in place.

  1. Drain the nodes by looping through the output of the default-pool's nodes and running the kubectl drain command on each individual node:
for node in $(kubectl get nodes -l cloud.google.com/gke-nodepool=default-pool -o=name); do kubectl drain --force --ignore-daemonsets --grace-period=10 "$node"; done

The command above will evict pods from the specified node and cordon the node so that no new pods can be created on it. If the available resources allow, pods are redeployed on a different node.

  1. Once your node has been drained, check in on your gb-frontend deployment's replica count:
kubectl describe deployment gb-frontend | grep ^Replicas

The output may resemble something like this:

Replicas: 5 desired | 5 updated | 5 total | 0 available | 5 unavailable

After draining a node, your deployment could have as little as 0 replicas available, as indicated by the output above. Without any pods available, your application is effectively down. Let's try draining the nodes again, except this time with a pod disruption budget in place for your application.

  1. First bring the drained nodes back by uncordoning them. The command below allows pods to be scheduled on the node again:
for node in $(kubectl get nodes -l cloud.google.com/gke-nodepool=default-pool -o=name); do kubectl uncordon "$node"; done
  1. Once again check in on the status of your deployment:
kubectl describe deployment gb-frontend | grep ^Replicas

The output should now resemble the following, with all 5 replicas available:

Replicas: 5 desired | 5 updated | 5 total | 5 available | 0 unavailable
  1. Create a pod disruption budget that will declare the minimum number of available pods to be 4:
kubectl create poddisruptionbudget gb-pdb --selector run=gb-frontend --min-available 4
  1. Once again, drain one of your cluster's nodes and observe the output:
for node in $(kubectl get nodes -l cloud.google.com/gke-nodepool=default-pool -o=name); do kubectl drain --timeout=30s --ignore-daemonsets --grace-period=10 "$node"; done

After successfully evicting one of your application's pods, it will loop through the following:

evicting pod default/gb-frontend-597d4d746c-fxsdg evicting pod default/gb-frontend-597d4d746c-tcrf2 evicting pod default/gb-frontend-597d4d746c-kwvmv evicting pod default/gb-frontend-597d4d746c-6jdx5 error when evicting pod "gb-frontend-597d4d746c-fxsdg" (will retry after 5s): Cannot evict pod as it would violate the pod's disruption budget. error when evicting pod "gb-frontend-597d4d746c-tcrf2" (will retry after 5s): Cannot evict pod as it would violate the pod's disruption budget. error when evicting pod "gb-frontend-597d4d746c-6jdx5" (will retry after 5s): Cannot evict pod as it would violate the pod's disruption budget. error when evicting pod "gb-frontend-597d4d746c-kwvmv" (will retry after 5s): Cannot evict pod as it would violate the pod's disruption budget.
  1. Press CTRL+C to exit the command.

  2. Check your deployments status once again:

kubectl describe deployment gb-frontend | grep ^Replicas

The output should now read:

Replicas: 5 desired | 5 updated | 5 total | 4 available | 1 unavailable

Until Kubernetes is able to deploy a 5th pod on a different node in order to evict the next one, the remaining pods will remain available in order to adhere to the PDB. In this example, the pod disruption budget was configured to indicate min-available but a PDB can also be configured to define a max-unavailable. Either value can be expressed as an integer representing a pod count, or a percentage of total pods.

Congratulations!

You learned how you can create a container-native load balancer through ingress in order to take advantage of more efficient load balancing and routing. You ran a simple load test on a GKE application and observed its baseline CPU and memory utilization, as well as how it responds to spikes in traffic. Additionally you configured liveness and readiness probes along with a pod disruption budget to ensure your applications' availability. These tools and techniques in conjunction with each other contribute to an overall efficiency to how your application can run on GKE by minimizing extraneous network traffic, defining meaningful indicators of a well-behaved application and improving application availability.

Next steps / Learn more

Check out these resources to learn more about the topics covered in this lab:

Google Cloud training and certification

...helps you make the most of Google Cloud technologies. Our classes include technical skills and best practices to help you get up to speed quickly and continue your learning journey. We offer fundamental to advanced level training, with on-demand, live, and virtual options to suit your busy schedule. Certifications help you validate and prove your skill and expertise in Google Cloud technologies.

Manual Last Updated: March 12, 2024

Lab Last Tested: March 12, 2024

Copyright 2024 Google LLC All rights reserved. Google and the Google logo are trademarks of Google LLC. All other company and product names may be trademarks of the respective companies with which they are associated.